In 2025, first-time authors will face a surprising reality: over 500,000 new self-published books are expected to hit the market in English alone (Bowker, 2023). With that kind of volume, readers are overwhelmed—and authors face a massive challenge. While most new writers focus on racking up ratings, the truth is that authentic reviews from real readers carry far more weight than volume alone.

That’s why learning how to get book reviews as a new author is more important than ever. A few truthful, thoughtful reader insights can do more for your credibility than a dozen vague five-star ratings. But how do you get those first honest reviews without falling into shady tactics or wasting time begging strangers online?

You’ve poured your heart into writing your book. Now it’s time to turn readers into reviewers, the right way. In this guide, we’ll walk you through proven strategies to ethically and effectively get those crucial early reviews that build momentum and trust.

In This Article

• Understand the Review Landscape in 2025
• Prepare Before Reaching Out for Reviews
• Build a Beta Reader and ARC Review Team
• Use Book Discovery Platforms That Work for New Authors
• Stay Ethical and Transparent in Your Ask
• Leverage Social Media Without Sounding Desperate
• Follow Up to Maximize Results and Respect Reviewers
• Use Reviews in Your Marketing, Even If Few
• Paws and Reflect: Wrapping It Up

Understand the Review Landscape in 2025

In 2025, getting reviews as a first-time author involves more than simply asking people to say something nice about your book. Reader expectations have evolved, and platforms like Amazon and Goodreads have cracked down on inauthentic or incentivized reviews. New authors must adapt by understanding not just how to get reviews—but the right kinds of reviews.

There are several types of reviews to consider, each serving different purposes:

• Beta reader feedback is pre-publication input to improve your story or writing style.
• Editorial reviews come from industry professionals or publications and carry external credibility.
• ARC (Advance Review Copy) reviews are tied to promotional timelines and help drive early momentum.
• Organic reader reviews occur post-launch and reflect typical reader experience.

While it’s tempting for first-time authors to aim for volume, platforms prioritize quality. A few detailed, insightful reviews from real readers often lead to better results than dozens of one-sentence, five-star ratings.

Take author Jennie Nash, whose early readers helped refine her book before launch. She focused on meaningful feedback during beta rounds, which upgraded the final draft and seeded enthusiastic ARC reviews. Her approach shows that review quality doesn’t just come after launch—it’s cultivated beforehand.

Setting realistic expectations is crucial. Not all readers will finish or review your book—even if they express interest. Instead of seeking mass approval, focus on getting your book into the right hands with a clear strategy tailored for review engagement. When you understand the landscape, you waste less time and gain far more trust.

Prepare Before Reaching Out for Reviews

Approaching potential reviewers prematurely is one of the biggest pitfalls for new authors. If your manuscript is still rough, your cover isn’t genre-appropriate, or your blurb lacks clarity, even the most generous reader won’t feel compelled to leave a positive—or honest—review.

Get Your Book “Review-Ready”

Start with a self-assessment:

• Manuscript: Fully edited (ideally professionally), proofread, and formatted for eBook and print.
• Cover design: Professionally designed to match your genre. A generic or off-genre cover can instantly turn off reviewers.
• Book description: Clear, hook-driven, and aligns with reader expectations in your niche.
• Metadata: Ensure you have an ISBN, accurate genre classification, and relevant comp titles ready.

Next, define your ideal reader. Are you writing for cozy mystery fans or dystopian YA readers? Reviewers want to feel like your book was written with them in mind. When your pitch aligns with a reader’s interests, they’re far more likely to reply—and eventually review.

Take the time to craft personalized outreach emails. Mention why you’re reaching out to them specifically, refer to their recent reads or reviews, and summarize your book in two compelling sentences. Offer different file formats—ePub, PDF, or print—based on their preferences.

Ultimately, how well you prepare before requesting reviews will determine how many responses you get, and how seriously they take your work. First impressions matter—and they start before anyone reads your first page.

Build a Beta Reader and ARC Review Team

Before launch day ever arrives, smart authors build a two-tier team: beta readers who help shape the book, and ARC reviewers who help spread the word. These early readers form your first community of advocates—and sometimes your most loyal fans.

Where to Find Beta and ARC Readers

Look for genre-aligned communities on platforms like:

• Facebook Groups (e.g., “Historical Romance Beta Readers”)
• Goodreads genre forums
• Discord writing servers or Reddit’s r/BetaReaders

Engage in these groups months before your outreach. Offer to beta read for others first—reciprocity builds trust.

Tools to Streamline the Process

Platforms like StoryOrigin and BookFunnel allow you to distribute secure copies, collect responses, and track who fulfills their review promises. You can even manage your email sequences there.

A great example comes from fantasy author Livia Blackburne, who shared how her ARC team not only provided visibility during launch week but also helped flag final typos and plot questions in beta stage. By involving them early and communicating updates, she created a sense of investment among readers.

When inviting betas or ARC reviewers, emphasize one message: you’re asking for honest impressions, not praise. The more authentic the review, the more value it holds. Lead with professionalism, respect their time, and make it easy for them to succeed.

Use Book Discovery Platforms That Work for New Authors

The right platform can help you get book reviews as a new author without relying on your personal network. But not all services are created equal—some charge high fees, others offer minimal vetting of reviewers. Knowing where to start saves time and frustration.

Top Platforms for Debut Authors

• BookSirens: Connects indie authors with verified readers by genre. You can view reader profiles and approve requests before sending ARCs.
• Hidden Gems: Offers curated review service with a strong reviewer base. Requires some investment, but the review quality is generally high.
• Reedsy Discovery: Great for visibility if you’re looking for editorial-style reviews from enthusiastic readers and bloggers.
• BookSprout: A budget-friendly alternative with built-in tracking and gentle reminders to encourage reviews.

Compare these options based on your genre, budget, and timeline. For example, romance authors may thrive on Hidden Gems, while science fiction indies often find a following on BookSirens.

Make sure your listing is airtight. That includes a compelling hook, professional cover, relevant tags, and proper formatting. The more polished your presentation, the more interest you’ll attract—and from the right readers.

When reviewing applications or reader profiles, prioritize alignment over quantity. One thoughtful reviewer who loves your genre is better than ten who don’t finish the book.

If your upcoming launch includes a visual component—say, a fantasy cover with lush worldbuilding—consider pairing your platform listing with a Cover Reveal Interview through Book Barker. It not only adds visibility but also offers early credibility that makes readers curious.

Stay Ethical and Transparent in Your Ask

It’s easy to unintentionally cross lines when asking for reviews—especially as a new author excited to get traction. But trust-based marketing means doing things by the book, literally and figuratively. Ethics in review requests protect both your reputation and your long-term success.

What NOT to Do

Here are common mistakes to steer clear of:

• Offering payment for a positive review (explicitly or implicitly)
• Failing to disclose that a review copy was provided for free
• Requesting a five-star review instead of an honest opinion
• Badgering or guilt-tripping readers who haven’t reviewed yet

Instead, approach with transparency. A sample outreach might read: “I’m offering early access to my debut novel in hopes of receiving honest, thoughtful feedback on Amazon or Goodreads. If the story speaks to you, I’d love to hear your honest take.”

Remember that platforms, especially Amazon, take review integrity seriously. Authors who violate terms risk having all their reviews—and sometimes accounts—restricted or removed.

If a reviewer agrees to read but never delivers, don’t chase them aggressively. A polite follow-up is fine (we’ll get to that in the next section), but respect that people’s schedules change. Reviewers aren’t owed anything except your professionalism and gratitude.

By clearly positioning your ask—and doing it with ethics—you set yourself apart as a professional, even if you’re just starting.

Leverage Social Media Without Sounding Desperate

Social media can be a powerful engine for visibility and connection—if you use it wisely. Shouting into the void with generic “Please review my book!” posts wears thin quickly. Instead, think attraction over promotion.

Create Shareable Moments

What draws someone into your world? Start with content that builds curiosity:

• Highlight a compelling quote with a subtle “ARC readers welcome—DM me!” prompt
• Use Instagram Reels or TikTok to show a behind-the-scenes look at your writing process
• Ask discussion questions related to your book’s themes

These posts create micro-engagements that spark genuine interest. When someone comments or responds, that’s your moment to offer a review copy privately.

Build Your Reviewer Funnel

On platforms like Instagram or Facebook, you can pin a post inviting followers to become early readers. Share the link to your signup form or direct them to your newsletter with an exclusive ARC offer.

Author Ayana Gray, for example, leveraged her Instagram platform with countdown reels for her debut release, teasing content and inviting advance readers in her Stories. Her campaign felt like an invitation, not a sales pitch—and generated enthusiastic reviews as a result.

Whatever platform you choose, make it feel like you’re offering something special, not asking for a favor. Readers are more willing to support an excited, respectful author than one who sounds desperate or spammy.

Follow Up to Maximize Results and Respect Reviewers

Imagine this: someone eagerly accepts your ARC, then… silence. It’s a common scenario—but it doesn’t have to mean failure. Strategic, respectful follow-up can gently nudge readers into action without making them uncomfortable.

Timing Is Everything

Wait 7–10 days after the reviewer receives the book before sending a short check-in message. Your tone can be friendly and casual:

“Hi [Name], just checking in—hope you’re enjoying the ARC of my debut! If you’re still planning to leave a review, I’d be so grateful. No pressure—I totally understand how busy reading lists can get.”

Tools like BookFunnel’s reader tracking or MailerLite’s segmented campaigns make this easier to automate while still feeling personal.

Thank and Encourage Cross-Posting

Once someone leaves a review, thank them sincerely. A simple “Thank you so much—your thoughts mean the world” goes a long way. If feasible, you can mention how helpful it would be if they share on both Amazon and Goodreads, or post on social media.

Respect and professionalism build goodwill. Some of your first reviewers may become recurring cheerleaders for future releases—treat them accordingly.

The follow-up phase is where many new authors stumble. With clarity, sincerity, and timing, you’ll see more reviews come through—and deepen your reviewer relationships in the process.

Use Reviews in Your Marketing, Even If Few

Don’t wait for a mountain of reviews before using them to market your book. One honest, enthusiastic review can do more for your credibility than a dozen generic blurbs.

How to Highlight Reviews Strategically

Repurpose review snippets across multiple platforms:

• Quote them in graphics for Instagram or Pinterest
• Add blurbs to your Amazon A+ content or book description
• Include one-liner testimonials in your newsletter footer
• Create a reader praise section on your website

Even critical reviews have value. A thoughtful three-star review often reveals the reviewer actually read and engaged with your book. You can use such feedback to refine future projects or reassure potential readers that your audience is honest, not curated.

When debut author Ava Reid received a mix of reviews on her first fantasy novel, she embraced key phrases—even from less-than-perfect scores—to highlight the book’s atmosphere and character depth. That transparency built credibility with prospective readers who wanted a “real” reading experience.

Over time, your reviews will naturally evolve—more organic readers will chime in as your visibility grows. Until then, use what you have with intention and humility. It’s a foundational part of learning how to get book reviews as a new author that actually work for you long-term.

Paws and Reflect: Wrapping It Up

Getting honest book reviews as a first-time author in 2025 may seem daunting, but with the right tools and mindset, it’s entirely achievable. From building a strong ARC team to using ethical outreach and leveraging effective platforms, every action you take sets the stage for long-term credibility. Remember, it’s not about racking up stars—it’s about connecting with reviewers who genuinely engage with your work.

By implementing even a few of the above strategies, you’ll be well on your way to get book reviews as a new author that actually help build trust and momentum. Focus on quality, meet your readers where they are, and follow up with authenticity. Start small, stay consistent, and keep your paws on the pulse of what readers value most.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I get my first book reviews as a new author?

To receive your initial book reviews, start by ensuring your manuscript is polished and ready for readers. Next, engage beta readers or create an Advance Review Copy (ARC) team by connecting with genre-specific communities online. Utilize book discovery platforms and social media to reach out for reviews while maintaining transparency. Request honest feedback rather than mere praise—this approach will bolster your credibility more effectively than accumulating numerous superficial ratings.

What should I consider before asking for book reviews?

Before soliciting reviews, ensure your book is professionally presented, including a well-crafted description and an eye-catching cover. Identify your target readership and tailor your outreach accordingly. Preparation is crucial: compile all necessary metadata and offer reviewers options for receiving digital or physical copies. A thoughtful, personalized approach not only increases response rates but also projects professionalism to potential reviewers.

What is the difference between beta readers and ARC readers?

Beta readers are individuals who provide feedback on a manuscript before it’s published and help authors make necessary revisions. ARC readers receive the finalized version of a book prior to its release, focusing on generating early reviews. Both groups play vital roles in shaping your book’s reception: beta readers help enhance the content, while ARC readers assist in building pre-launch buzz and credibility through early endorsements.

How can I ethically request book reviews?

When asking for reviews, it’s essential to maintain transparency and honesty. Clearly state that the copy provided is complimentary and encourage candid opinions. Never pressure reviewers for favorable ratings, and always adhere to the guidelines set by platforms like Amazon. Craft your review request with respect and genuine interest in the reviewer’s thoughts to build trust and foster long-term relationships with your audience.

Which platforms are best for new authors to find reviewers?

New authors can benefit from several book discovery platforms designed to connect them with active readers. Options like BookSirens, Hidden Gems, and Reedsy Discovery are tailored for debut authors seeking authentic reviews. Be sure to compare the features, such as reader engagement and pricing, to find a suitable fit for your book. Maximizing exposure on these platforms can significantly improve your chances of receiving meaningful reviews.

How can I effectively leverage social media for reviews?

Using social media to secure book reviews requires a strategic approach. Instead of direct requests for reviews, engage your audience with related content, such as teaser excerpts or insights into your writing process. Use stories and posts to subtly invite ARC applications without coming off as desperate. Engage actively with potential readers, and create interest in your book, prompting organic requests for reviews from engaged followers.

What should I do if I don’t receive reviews after reaching out?

If you find yourself without reviews after your outreach, consider following up gently with a reminder one week after your initial request. Use this opportunity to thank them for considering your work and encourage any feedback they may have. If a reviewer doesn’t respond after your follow-up, focus on expanding your outreach efforts to new contacts or leveraging different platforms to connect with potential reviewers.